ⓘ High Crimes
High Crimes is a 2002 American legal thriller film directed by Carl Franklin and starring Ashley Judd and Morgan Freeman, reunited from the 1997 film Kiss the Girls. The screenplay by Yuri Zeltser and Grace Cary Bickley is based on Joseph Finders 1998 novel of the same name.
Attorney Claire Kubik Ashley Judd and her woodworker husband Tom James Caviezel find their idyllic life in Marin County, California shattered when, during a Christmas shopping excursion in San Franciscos Union Square, he is captured by the US Federal Bureau of Investigation and charged with the murders of nine villagers in a remote village in El Salvador in 1988. Claire learns Toms real name is Ronald Chapman, and she is shocked to discover he was a covert military operative serving in the Marines and has been on the run for the past twelve years.
Tom admits he was present at the scene of the mass murders but staunchly denies any involvement in the killings. He insists he has been scapegoated in order to protect the real culprit, Major James Hernandez Juan Carlos Hernandez, who has become the aide of Brigadier General Bill Marks Bruce Davison.
First Lieutenant Terence Embry Adam Scott is assigned to defend Tom, but his youth and lack of experience prompt Claire to decide to assist professionally in defending her husband. When she realizes she needs help from someone familiar with the workings of a military court, she hires Charlie Grimes Morgan Freeman, an embittered former military attorney who has a grudge against the military brass, to assist her. Three of the five key witnesses, who previously testified Tom was guilty, have died under seemingly mysterious circumstances, raising Claire and Charlies suspicions. As the trial proceeds, they uncover a massive cover-up perpetrated by one of the militarys highest-ranking officials. Also creating problems are the sudden appearance of a resident Emilio Rivera of the village where the mass murder took place, who insists Tom was responsible; Embrys romantic involvement with Claires irresponsible sister Jackie Amanda Peet, which leads Claire to assume that he leaked details about secrets she has uncovered to the prosecution; and Charlies falling off the wagon after more than a year of sobriety.
The Salvadorian witness identifies an injured Hernandez as the culprit responsible for a bombing incident prior to the massacre. Claire recovers classified medical files from the FBI as evidence of the cover-up. Claire blackmails Marks by threatening to reveal what she knows about the cover-up and asks him to make the case go away; the next day, the U.S. Defense Department has the case thrown out of court due to "security reasons".
Just as Claire is about to celebrate her victory in court, Charlie discovers the truth: Tom had murdered one of the witnesses in front of his family. The widow who witnessed the act described Toms having tossed his gun from one hand to the other a habit Tom displayed with keys and other objects throughout the film and his shooting his gun first using one hand, then the other revealing his ambidexterity. The match between these descriptions also indicated that Tom committed the massacre and also murdered two of the other key witnesses years prior to his arrest. After Tom overhears Claire talking to Charlie on the phone, a short scuffle between Claire and Tom ensues, during which Claire fears for her life. The Salvadoran witness shoots Tom through the window, and the film ends with Charlie and Claire partnering a new law firm.
- Dawn Hudson as Lieutenant Colonel LaPierre
- Morgan Freeman as Charlie Grimes
- Julie Remala as Lisa Stenstrom
- Emilio Rivera as Salvadoran Man
- Ashley Judd as Claire Kubik
- Michael Gaston as Major Waldron
- Jim Caviezel as Tom Kubik/Ron Chapman
- Dendrie Taylor as Lola
- Adam Scott as First Lieutenant Terence Embry
- Amanda Peet as Jackie Grimaldi
- Bruce Davison as Brigadier General Bill Marks
- Tom Bower as Special Agent Mullins
- Juan Carlos Hernandez as Major James Hernandez
- Jude Ciccolella as Colonel Farrell
- Michael Shannon as Troy Abbott
- Paula Jai Parker as Gracie
3. Critical reception
Rotten Tomatoes reported a "rotten" 31% rating, based on 133 reviews, while Metacritic reported the film had an average score of 48 out of 100, based on 33 reviews.
A.O. Scott of The New York Times thought Ashley Judd and Morgan Freeman "make a muddled genre exercise seem a lot better than it is. Ms. Judd, always brisk and appealing, is capable of fine acting when the mood strikes Mr. Freeman shows himself, once again, incapable of giving a bad performance." He added Carl Franklins direction "is far from terrible, but it feels singularly uninspired, a flurry of fast, expository scenes and suspense-movie setups." He felt the plot twist "renders everything that came before completely nonsensical" and concluded, "If you figure it out, please let me know. On second thought, dont, but please drop a line to the folks at 20th Century Fox, since Im sure theyre just as baffled as the rest of us."
Roger Ebert of the Chicago Sun-Times rated the film three out of four stars and commented, "I do like the way director Carl Franklin and writers Yuri Zeltser and Cary Bickley. play both ends against the middle, so that the audience has abundant evidence to believe two completely conflicting theories of what actually happened. High Crimes works to keep us involved and make us care. The unfolding of various versions of the long-ago massacre is handled by Franklin in flashbacks that show how one camera angle can refute what another angle seems to prove. And if we feel, toward the end, a little whiplashed by the plot manipulations, well, thats what the movie promises and thats what the movie delivers."
Mick LaSalle of the San Francisco Chronicle said the film "has some faults, but it manages to keep its audience either angry or jumpy from start to finish. The dramatic focus of High Crimes gets a bit fuzzy in the last half hour - it starts to feel as if some scenes get replayed. Still, the scenes are never dull, and the movie recovers for the big finish. Only one thing is lacking throughout, not a big thing, but big enough to mention. We keep hearing about what great lawyers Claire and Grimes are, but theres no great courtroom scene. In that, High Crimes is too much like real life. It gives us court with no courtroom fireworks."
Michael OSullivan of the Washington Post said the film "satisfies a hunger for the basics: a decent mystery to chew on, a bit of juicy suspense, maybe a plot twist as garnish. The fare is all on the standard menu, but it goes down well just the same. Chalk that up to a cast the director can trust enough to step out of the way and let do their jobs. And yes, theres a twist ending, but dont kid yourself that you wont see it coming. Surprising? Maybe not. Satisfying? Not half as much as watching Freeman and Judd, two compelling performers who seem to enjoy each others company almost as much as we do."
Robert Koehler of Variety called the film "utterly conventional" and Ashley Judds performance "so resolutely humorless and businesslike that Freemans gruffly affectionate warmth becomes doubly valuable, though not nearly enough to lend this generic project any special character. Most disillusioning is how director Carl Franklin, once known for tense storytelling and unpredictable characters, goes about his task here with a visible lack of inspiration. The screenwriting team of Yuri Zeltser and Cary Bickley has tweaked Joseph Finders novel considerably. Character alterations, refinements, re-locations and plot substitutions produce a rabbits warren full of holes in an almost laughably complex plot. By the time the third act exhaustedly appears, its hardly a wonder that some major characters have no idea where other major characters are, or what theyre doing."
4. Awards and nominations
Morgan Freeman was nominated for the NAACP Image Award for Outstanding Actor in a Motion Picture but lost to Denzel Washington in John Q, the actors fourth consecutive win in this category.
5. Home media
20th Century Fox Home Entertainment released the Region 1 DVD on August 27, 2002. The film is in anamorphic widescreen format with audio tracks in English, Spanish, and French and subtitles in English and Spanish. Bonus features include commentary by director Carl Franklin and six featurettes about the making of the film.
High Crimes is also available on Blu-ray Disc.